5 Things Every New Yorker Looks For in a Great Deli
A great deli is about more than just grabbing lunch
Ask any New Yorker what separates a great deli from an average one, and you'll probably get a passionate answer. Authentic delis are built on tradition, quality ingredients, and little details that locals have come to expect.
Gruby's New York Deli has been bringing those traditions to Hilton Head Island since 1986 and proudly serves the same authentic flavors at our Atlanta location.
5 things every New Yorker expects from a great deli
1. Fresh New York-Style Bagels
A great deli starts with a great bagel, and ours are authentic New York City bagels direct from the Bronx! Crisp on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside, a proper New York-style bagel should stand on its own before the cream cheese is even added. Breakfast sandwiches, lox, or a simple toasted bagel all begin with that unmistakable texture and flavor.
2. Hand-Sliced Pastrami & Corned Beef
Nothing says "New York deli" quite like fresh pastrami and corned beef sliced to order. Thick, tender, and piled high on fresh rye bread, these classics have earned their place on deli menus for generations. Every bite should remind you why these sandwiches have become legends.
3. The B.E.C. on a Roll
Few breakfasts are more iconic than a bacon, egg, and cheese on a Kaiser roll. Fresh eggs, crispy bacon, melted American cheese, and a warm roll create a combination that's fueled busy New Yorkers for decades. Add salt, pepper, and ketchup if you like, and you've got one of the city's most recognizable comfort foods.
4. Dr. Brown's Soda
Long before craft sodas became popular, New Yorkers were reaching for a bottle of Dr. Brown's alongside their favorite deli sandwich. Cel-Ray, Black Cherry, Cream Soda, and Root Beer have become part of deli culture for generations. Pairing one with a Reuben or pastrami sandwich isn't just nostalgic. It's part of the authentic New York experience. (Photo: The Twin Towers, Hot corned beef, hot pastrami on rye with coleslaw and Russian dressing)
5. Pickles on the Side
A sandwich isn't complete without a crisp pickle spear resting next to it. That familiar crunch balances the richness of a stacked deli sandwich and has become one of those simple traditions people expect the moment their plate reaches the table. Small details like this help turn lunch into a true deli experience.
-
Gruby's New York Deli has been serving Hilton Head Island since 1986, bringing authentic New York-style deli traditions to the Lowcountry. From fresh bagels and hand-sliced meats to overstuffed sandwiches and homemade soups, every meal is prepared with the quality and generous portions you'd expect from a classic New York deli.
-
Yes. Gruby's serves authentic New York-style bagels that pair perfectly with classic cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon, breakfast sandwiches, and deli favorites. No matter if you're stopping in for breakfast or picking up a dozen to take home, our bagels are a customer favorite.
-
Some of our most popular menu items include our Reuben, pastrami on rye, corned beef sandwiches, turkey club, and classic breakfast bagel sandwiches. We also serve fresh salads, wraps, homemade soups, and plenty of New York deli specialties to satisfy every appetite.
-
Yes! Gruby's provides catering for business meetings, family gatherings, office lunches, parties, and special events. Our catering menu features sandwich platters, bagel trays, breakfast options, desserts, and other deli favorites that make feeding a group easy and delicious.
-
Gruby's proudly serves customers at two locations. Our original restaurant has been a Hilton Head Island tradition since 1986, and we're also proud to bring authentic New York deli favorites to our Atlanta location. No matter if you're a local resident or visiting the area, you'll find the same quality food, friendly service, and authentic deli experience at both restaurants.
Authentic New York Deli in Hilton Head, SC and Atlanta, GA
Great delis don't just serve food. They preserve traditions that have been passed down for generations. Fresh bagels, hand-sliced meats, classic breakfast sandwiches, deli favorites, and those familiar finishing touches are all part of what makes Gruby's a destination for locals and visitors alike. Stop by our Hilton Head Island location or visit us in Atlanta and enjoy a true taste of New York.
